The Best Horror Novels… Ever

I love horror. I love reading horror novels, watching horror films, listening to horror-themed rock. Also, I write horror stories! I like to think I’m a horror author before being a writer of any other genre.

Naturally, I’ve searched once or twice for the best horror novels ever written. Different website and publications have different lists, but a certain clutch of books and authors cropped up more than others.

Ladies and gentlemen, I present for your reading pleasure: a compilation of all those horror novels that have made the most impact on the world of terror and suspense. I’ve already read a few, so I’ll write my own summaries where I can and leave the rest to Amazon. We’ll work our way through in chronological order, shall we? Without further ado, let us plunge into a world of untrammeled terror… The best horror novels ever.

Memento Mori: 19th Century Horror Novels

Frankenstein; or, the Modern Prometheus – Mary Shelley, 1818

Mary Shelley wrote Frankenstein to “curdle the blood and quicken the beatings of the heart”. It was her attempt to beat Lord Byron and Percy Shelley at writing a scary story during a stay at Lake Geneva. Its themes and concept of a scientist who plays God and creates a living creature from stolen parts of corpses have resonated through the years. Horror begins here…

Carmilla – Sheridan Le Fanu, 1871-72

Le Fanu’s seminal vampire tale predates Bram Stoker’s opus by 25 years. Its gothic, sapphic and bloody visuals laid the template for Hammer Horror a century later. It’s a surprisingly contemporary-feeling read; pacey and gripping. You wouldn’t know it was written over a century ago.

The young narrator, Laura, is staying at an isolated castle when a carriage accident occurs outside. A young girl, Carmilla, is brought to stay at the castle. She doesn’t join in prayers and sleeps by day. Meanwhile, a strange malady appears to kill of the people of a nearby town…

Dracula – Bram Stoker, 1897

A heavyweight entry in the gothic canon, Dracula has plenty of merits to distinguish it from its peers. A epistolary novel comprising diary entries, telegrams and letters, its presentation feels very modern, and its inclusion of (then) modern technology like phonographs and its globetrotting plot marks it as something of a techno-thriller of its day. An essential horror novel.

Our tale begins as lawyer Jonathan Harker visits Count Dracula in Transylvania. The Count does not eat or drink and soon Harker finds himself incarcerated. Later, back in England, a mysterious dark figure begins to haunt Harker’s fiance Mina and her friend Lucy…

The Turn of the Screw – Henry James, 1898

The Turn of the Screw laid many of the foundations of the traditional ghost story. A fire flickers in the hearth as a troubled narrator recounts a disturbing tale of a remote manor house and the strange goings on within that might involve the secretive children of the estate. An unsuspecting (and unnamed) governess arrives at the manor and is plunged into a nightmare of her own…

Nocturnal Stirrings: Early Modern Horror Novels

At the Mountains of Madness – H.P. Lovecraft, 1936

Scientist William Dyer recounts an ill-fated trip to Antarctica, an adventure which leads to the discovery of a range of mysterious mountains that conceal an ancient city, long forgotten by any living thing on earth. As his tale progresses, the full horror of Dyer’s discovery is made clear.

Lovecraft’s brand of horror centres around the insignificance of earth in the face of ancient cosmic entities. Most of his stories are shorter, but At the Mountains of Madness gives him the sprawl to explore these themes in detail (though The Call of Cthulhu is a good bite-sized entry to his mythos).

Rebecca – Daphne du Maurier, 1938

Rebecca follows in the footsteps of the gothic novels of the 19th century. The unnamed heroine of the novel falls in love with the enigmatic Maxim de Winter, whose home at Manderley Hall is haunted by the memory of his deceased first wife, Rebecca.

Manderley is as much a character as the cast of the novel, and its halls hold the secret of the first Mrs de Winter’s untimely passing. But even our protagonist begins to guess as the truth, we discover all is not as it seems. Rebecca may yet have her revenge on the world she’s left behind…

The Bad Seed – William March, 1954

Before The Omen and The Exorcist popularised evil children, there was The Bad Seed.

Rhoda Penmark is a pretty, sweet, pigtailed eight year-old. But when one of her classmates ends up dead, her mother starts to wonder. Could Rhoda’s prim demeanor conceal the cold, calculating mind of a killer? And if so, is she herself responsible for passing on the bad seed that made her so?

William March’s clipped, proper prose is the ideal vehicle for this exploration of psychological horror.

The Haunting of Hill House – Shirley Jackson, 1959

The Haunting of Hill House is fairly ahead of its time – found footage films of ghost hunters shacking up in haunted houses live in Hill House’s towering, crenelated shadow. It uses an unreliable narrator to chilling effect and manages a few jump scares along the way.

A supernatural investigator and his assistants arrive at Hill House to investigate the supernatural phenomena occurring there. But some of the clues to its hauntings may lie in its residents’ pasts…

Something Wicked this Way Comes – Ray Bradbury, 1962

Bradbury is a pleasure to read, his prose laced with poetry. Themes of childhood and innocence are bound into Something Wicked This Way Comes, a tale of two boys who enter a mysterious carnival where all is not as it seems.

Rosemary’s Baby – Ira Levin, 1967

Rosemary’s Baby is an essay in suspense and a stone-cold classic of the horror genre. Rosemary and her husband Guy move into the apartment of their dreams, dismissing the building’s history of witchcraft and the occult as an urban legend. But Rosemary becomes increasing uneasy as their neighbours take an interest in her relationship and, soon enough, her pregnancy.

Rosemary’s Baby works by stealth. Rosemary’s uncertainty is ours – could her suspicions be real? Could their neighbours gatherings be something other than parties? Might her dimly remembered nightmares be true…?

Golden Age of Grotesque: 70s and 80s Horror Books

Hell House – Richard Matheson, 1971

You know how some books are able to do the job of a horror film and really get the hairs on the back of your neck up? Hell House is one of them. It shares some DNA with The Haunting of Hill House, but while Jackson’s book works by stealth and implication, Matheson is only too happy to bolster the creepiness of his work with violence.

The book concerns a parasychologist and mediums who stay in a haunted house to investigate life after death. Needless to say, the house gives them plenty of material to work with, and things spiral steadily out of control…

The Rats – James Herbert, 1974

Okay, I’ll level with you. This one didn’t pop up on that many lists, but it really deserves a place on mine. The Rats is James Herbert’s debut novel and, while he got a little more literary as he went on, The Rats is a short, nasty, bitey read. His writing has something urgent and raw about it which adds to its horror, as it describes a plague of huge rats that grower ever bolder, attacking the public with increasing viciousness.

The Rats has an overarching narrative and a hero inhabiting it, but it’s punctuated with individual vignettes which keep the horror levels high, and it’s these that stick in your head the longest.

Interview with the Vampire – Anne Rice, 1976

No one did more to update vampires than Anne Rice. Prior to Interview with the Vampire, bloodsuckers were monstrous or seductive archetypes, but Rice makes the personalities of her vampires the heart of her story. The story sees the Byronic vampire Lestat turn Louis into one of his kind, a transformation that will set him on a journey drenched in blood and pain. The novel’s thoughtfulness is weighed beautifully against its goriness and sensuality.

Ghost Story – Peter Straub, 1979

Ghost Story boasts one of the most hooking opening chapters in horror. It’s a sprawling tale of five men who must confront an evil buried deep in their past, and escalates to a trialing climax.

The Elementals – Michael McDowell, 1981

It all begins with a strange rite at a funeral involving an open casket and hereditary blade. From there, McDowell’s Southern Gothic tale takes us to the Gulf coast, where our protagonists are staying near to a house abandoned for so long that the sands have claimed half the building.

The Elementals keeps its cards close to its chest for the most part, digging into the superstitions and relationships between the two families at its core whilst keeping the horror at hand by way of juju rituals and forays into the haunted house. When the terror mounts for the climax, it’s all the more intense for it.

The Woman in Black – Susan Hill, 1983

Susan Hill’s gothic tales are lovingly constructed, crafted to feel like the classic ghost stories of the past. The Woman In Black beings with tales round a fire, and concerns a scholarly young solicitor summoned to an isolated mansion on the coast. The book delivers on the promises set by its premise.

Pet Semetary – Stephen King, 1983

Stephen King is the most prolific writer of horror in the world. His impressive oeuvre encompasses over fifty novels, but Pet Semetary, the story of a graveyard where all that is buried might not stay down, seems a reader’s favourite.

Compared to his other works, Pet Semetary is quite a low-key affair, basing itself in family drama and pledging its cause to a particularly mournful, bleak brand of horror. Perhaps not the best introduction to King’s work, but one which has struck a particular chord with his fans.

The Books of Blood – Clive Barker, 1984-85

Clive Barker is a visionary, his stories startlingly original and impeccably written. He writes novels, but remains renowned for the Books of Blood, six volumes of five or six short stories, which provide some of the most horrifying Grand Guignol narratives ever. Things get very gory and definitely not for those of a sensitive disposition, but Barker is too much the craftsman for things to feel exploitative or gratuitous.

Beloved – Toni Morrison, 1987

Beloved isn’t a horror novel, but it appears on a great deal of must-read horror lists. To its credit, it is set in a horrifying world, that of black slavery. It may also feature ghosts, though Morrison’s metaphor-heavy prose keeps things ambiguous.

Beloved was inspired by the true story of a slave who murdered her own child rather than see her captured and taken back into slavery. In the story that slave is Sethe, who lives in Ohio, now freed. She believes her home is haunted and, when one of the other slaves she worked with returns to her, the past is stirred up. Soon after, a mysterious young woman arrives at Sethe’s house. She is the same age as Sethe’s murdered daughter would have been…

The Silence of the Lambs – Thomas Harris, 1988

In many ways, The Silence of the Lambs killed the horror novel. It supplied horror aficionados with all the gore and menace of a nasty paperback, but it was grounded in the realism of police procedure, not in the realms of fantasy or the supernatural. After The Silence of the Lambs, horror writers begged to have their books marketed as thrillers. It didn’t hurt that the novel’s breakout character, the cultured cannibal Dr Hannibal Lecter, was as instantly classic as any established horror film killer.

The novel follows the progress of FBI recruit Clarice Starling as she hunts a serial killer known as Buffalo Bill. She is mentored by an incarcerated Lecter and their exchanges form the tension at the heart of the book. It’s a gripping page turner, all too often overshadowed by its faithful film adaptation.

The Fifth Child – Doris Lessing, 1988

The Fifth Child may be from the tail-end of the eighties, but it feels like a much older ghost story. Harriet and David Lovatt want more than anything for a houseful of beautiful children. But their fifth child, Ben, is pale and ugly, violent and unlikeable. Harriet is afraid what she has given birth to.

The Fifth Child is a horror story on one level, but it’s also the sad tale of a child born into the wrong family – or perhaps something more. A contemporary gothic chiller.

The Girl Next Door – Jack Ketchum, 1989

Jack Ketchum is at the cutting edge (as it were) of horror. His books are lethally lean and spare no detail when it comes to splatter and gore. They grab you by the throat make you keep your eyes open even as the horror within them unfolds.

In The Girl Next Door things have an especially unsavoury flavour. We see through young David’s eyes as his neighbour Ruth, and her three boys take in an innocent teen, Meg, and her sister Susan after their parents are killed. The girls are kept imprisoned and their cruel treatment steadily escalates. Ketchum’s master stroke is in making the reader feel as complicit in their actions as narrator David. As with all of his work: approach with caution.

Carrion Comfort – Dan Simmons, 1989

It begins as three ‘mind-vampires’ – people with the Ability to bend others to their will and use them as they wish – meet to discuss the crimes and atrocities they have committed that year. But the trio are betrayed. Their evil alliance is ripped apart in a night of murder and mayhem.

Trying to make sense of it all is Sheriff Rob Gentry. Together with Natalie, daughter of a slain bystander, and Saul, a deathcamp survivor with old links to one of the vampires, the investigators are plunged deeper into an ever-evolving mystery…

Carrion Comfort is a sprawling, epic thriller. Near 1000 pages long, it tracks the hunt of its villains whilst giving its readers an uncomfortable glimpse into its monsters’ minds.

Fresh Hell: 90s and 00s Horror Books

Ring – Koji Suzuki, 1991

Ring is the only Japanese horror novel that pops up frequently on lists of the best horror novels ever around the internet, possibly as it as penetrated Western culture with its 2002 film adaptation.

The story begins when journalist Asakawa notices common features between the sudden deaths of four teenagers. His investigation leads him to the iconic cursed videotape – a VHS which holds a film of disparate disturbing images and which ends with a warning – whoever watches the film will die within seven days.

Asakawa is on a literal deadline to escape his fate – Ring is as gripping as it gets.

Intensity – Dean Koontz, 1995

Intensity is an absolute thriller. Its heroine, Chyna, arrives at the isolated house of her friend Laura, where she finds a family that treat her like their very own. But the happiness is shattered when a serial killer breaks into the house. Thus begins a cat-and-mouse page-turner and that doesn’t let up for a single page and which twists and turns in all the unexpected places.

Exquisite Corpse – Poppy Z. Brite, 1996

Exquisite Corpse is one of the more transgressive books on this list. But it’s also one of the most frequently cited on best-horror-ever shortlists. In London, incarcerated serial killer Andrew Compton plots his escape from prison – an escape that will take him across the Atlantic to Louisiana. Meanwhile, in New Orleans, Jay Byrne finds himself in the midst of a tattered love triangle and hiding a secret – that he is every bit as murderous as his English counterpart. Andrew and Jay’s lives are set on a deadly collision course. When the two killers meet, there will be blood.

Transgender author Poppy Z. Brite digs deep into the psyches of the novel’s cast – all the characters are gay – and laces the fear of HIV and AIDS into the book’s nasty themes of cannibalism and necrophilia. The content is extreme enough that even as an established author Brite struggled to get the book published. You have been warned.

House of Leaves – Mark Z. Danielewski, 2000

Horror has been taken in some pretty post-modern directions. House of Leaves is one of the more extreme examples; a novel inside a novel where formatting of text, images, footnotes and diagrams adds to the themes and imagery of the story itself. It demands your willingness to engage with it but as an immersive experience it’s original and often very effective.

Let the Right One In – John Avjde Linqvist, 2004

Every now and then, a vampire novel turns the genre on its head, like a sleeping bat suddenly righted. Let the Right One In is such a novel.

12 year-old Oskar lives in a dreary Stockholm suburb. He’s a misfit: friendless and a target for bullies. But when a mysterious girl appears at night outside his apartment block, Oskar finds someone who might be able to relate to him. Meanwhile, the body of a murdered boy is found in the nearby woods, drained of blood…

Let the Right One In is bleak in a particularly Scandi way. But it has more than a hint of Stephen King about its prose too. More sprawling than its adaptations, it’s a must-read for genre fans.

Fledgling – Octavia E. Butler, 2005

Fledgling begins as an amnesiac girl wakes in a cave. She’s blind and wounded, but soon discovers she has an appetite for blood and flesh. Heading out into the world, our fledgling vampire encounters an ally who helps her investigate her origins and rediscover who she is. Vampire novels are by their very nature horrifying, but Fledgling is more interested in the relationships formed between vampires and their willing prey, as well as in the sociology of a vampire nest.

Lunar Park – Bret Easton Ellis, 2005

Bret Easton Ellis is most famous for his novels Less Than Zero and American Psycho. The latter pushed the limits of horror (or violence, at least) so far that his publishers refused to take it. But it’s Lunar Park that appears most on the internet’s Best Horror lists.

Lunar Park is a ghost story, but it’s on Ellis’s terms. It’s as drug-and-drink-fuelled as his other work, but more concise than his stream-of-consciousness prior novels. But whilst it’s less kaleidoscopic, it’s more metafictional. Ellis himself is the main character; the book a fictional memoir of his life as he battles the (perhaps literal) ghost of his estranged father.

Haunted – Chuck Palahniuk, 2005

Haunted is another postmodern take on the genre, and could be the most disgustingly entertaining book on this list. Comprised of short stories bound up in an overarching narrative, Palahnuik’s live reading of the notorious Guts actually caused people to pass out. Not for the faint of heart – or the easily offended – but for those who want to see the limits of horror (and taste) pushed and broken, Haunted should do the trick.

War War Z – Max Brooks, 2006

An epistolary novel, World War Z collects the accounts of people from all around the world as the zombie apocalypse hits. It’s a dippable book – by switching characters and settings in every chapter, it can’t be said to be a page-turner in the traditional sense – but it’s visionary, with megahordes of zombies, underwater scenes and some bruising combat sequences laid out to a level of detail that has surely never been seen before in its genre. Brooks is a clear zombie aficionado, and his knowledge and flair propel zombies lurching into imaginative new territory.

Heart-Shaped Box – Joe Hill, 2007

Joe Hill has a legacy to live up to, but his bibliography is so far remarkably solid. Heart-Shaped Box is his debut, and lays down his hallmarks: tight plotting, channelled imagination and a penchant for rock and roll references.

John Dies at the End – David Wong, 2007

Of all the horror novels on this list, John Dies at the End might be the most surreal. David Wong plays himself as the narrator of a lurid tale as he recounts his adventures to a journalist. He and John are freelance detectives who specialise in the supernatural, and their latest case will take them to the very limits of imagination (and believability).

The novel started life as a web serial, and you can see traces of that pedigree in its episodic, freewheeling structure, as one segment tries to out-do the last in terms of gore and the bizarre. There are monsters made of meat, mysterious dead bodies, and projectile doggy diarrhoea. Take a deep breath.

New Blood: 2010 to Present Horror Novels

Penpal – Dathan Auerbach, 2012

Penpal is a novel of its times, based on creepypasta stories that author Dathan Auerbach posted online before coalescing into a cohesive narrative. Like any well-timed campfire story, urban myth or horror blog, Penpal can get pretty scary. I’m not ashamed to say I got up out of bed to check all my doors were locked after reading the opening chapters. Its amateur origins show through – the writing isn’t as polished as the more-traditionally published books on this list – but as a reflection of horror in the 2010s, Penpal is pretty bang on.

Night Film – Marisha Pessl, 2013

Night Film is slightly more than just a novel. Opening it is like beginning on your own investigation into the mystery of Ashley Cordova, daughter of enigmatic film director Stanislaus Cordova, found dead in an NY warehouse.

Our tale spans the horror and detective genres, and uses magazine articles, screenshots and transcripts to enrich the world it creates. As the story continues, so our own escape routes are cut off. A smart and immersive read.

Broken Monsters – Lauren Beukes, 2014

Broken Monsters isn’t actually a horror (see The Silence of the Lambs earlier on this list), but it seemed to crop up on quite a few ‘best horror’ lists, so it earns its spot on this one. It may not be a horror but it sure is horrifying; a particularly gritty police procedural thriller that kicks off with the find of a heavily mutilated body. It isn’t the first.

The Detroit setting is particularly evocative, the core story nice and nasty. There’s room to accommodate some subplots too, which are equally unafraid to get confrontational and dark.

Bird Box – Josh Malerman, 2014

A Netflix adaptation catapulted Bird Box into the spotlight in 2018. Or rather, a viral trend based on its premise did. In Bird Box, everyone is afraid to open their eyes, because what they might see could turn them mad, leading them to kill themselves.

The story is structured around flashbacks. As Malorie leads two children downriver, we learn a little more about the events leading to this apocalypse…

A Head Full of Ghosts – Paul Tremblay, 2015

I find that ‘referential’ horror novels are gaining in popularity – books which incorporate homages to classics (and obscures) of the genre into their own stories. A Head Full of Ghosts is on such book, and I really enjoyed  spotting references – when I wasn’t just plain gripped and terrified.

The story is related by grown-up Merry Barrett who, when she was eight, lived through the apparent possession and exorcism of her sister Marjorie. Merry doesn’t understand everything she sees (and if you know The Exorcist, the book’s central inspiration, you can guess some of what goes on) and she makes for excellent eyes to see the story through.

Things We Lost in the Fire – Marianna Enriquez, 2016

Things We Lost in the Fire frequently sneaks onto best horror novel lists despite being a short story collection. Argentine author Mariana Enriquez conjures tales of disaffected characters presented with the grotesque or unnatural. Often, Argentina and city of Buenos Aires become characters in their own right: humid, pungent and dangerous.

The short stories are not connected but they build to more than the sum of their parts. Together they paint a vivid and disturbing picture…

The Changeling – Victor LaValle, 2017

There is a point, about a hundred pages into this book, when things change. And they change hard. Up until then, The Changeling is a polite, literary novel. It concerns Apollo Kagwa, a loving husband and book dealer, as he becomes an excited new father.

However, a tragedy hits Apollo and life is realigned. Those he thought he could trust are now to be blame for destroying what he once held dear to him. The Changeling uses several fairy tale tropes to tell its affecting, thoughtful story.

The Silent Companions – Laura Purcell, 2018

Out of all contemporary authors, I think Laura Purcell is the most similar to me – a writer who clearly loves the tropes and moods of the gothic novel.

The Silent Companions is a Victorian ghost story. Recently widowed Elsie is sent to her late husband’s estate. There are locked doors, historical subplots and the silent companions themselves – painted wooden figures which surely can’t move around on their own… This is an absolute pleasure to read.

Liam Smith

Writing twisted gothic tales and drumming whilst I think up more.

2 thoughts to “The Best Horror Novels… Ever”

  1. I will try some of the ones here that I haven’t read (especially if they are on ‘the disc’!). From the descriptions, I like the sound of the HP Lovecraft, Henry James, Joe Hill, Clive Barker and Bret Easton Ellis novels. Also, a timely entry for Pet Semetary with the new movie just out. By the way, did you know Henry James lived in Rye? Lamb House.

    1. I’ve just finished a Clive Barker (Damnation Game) but Books of Blood are my favourite. You’ve picked out all authors I’ve already read! We must have very similar tastes!
      I did not know about Henry James. A good excuse to go to Rye and take a look!

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *